Two thirds of business managers don’t believe mental illness warrants time off work

Two thirds (69 per cent) of senior business managers and owners don’t believe that suffering from stress, anxiety or depression is a serious enough reason for employees to be off work, according to new research* from AXA PPP healthcare highlighting the stigma surrounding mental ill health in British businesses.

15 April 2015

Posted in Product

by Ben Faulkner (see media contact)

When asked how they would react if an employee they manage was suffering from a mental health issue, one in five said they would worry about the employee’s capability to do their job and one in six said they would worry about the consequences for themselves personally, such as it reflecting poorly on their management style or having to pick up additional work. This is despite 1 in 4 of managers acknowledging that they have experienced a mental health problem themselves – a finding that mirrors exactly the response of employees when asked the same question.

When asked if they would be honest with their line manager when calling in sick because they were suffering from stress, anxiety or depression, only 39 per cent of employees said they would tell the truth. For those that stated they would avoid telling the truth, 1 in 7 (15 per cent) said they were afraid they would not be believed, 1 in 4 (23 per cent) were afraid of being judged and 23 per cent preferred to keep their health issues private. Seven per cent said they feared their line manager’s reaction to being told the truth.

There was considerable scepticism about the seriousness of employers’ commitment to dealing with mental ill health at work. Forty six per cent of employees surveyed thought their employer didn’t take mental health issues seriously and just 12 per cent of bosses thought their industry was affected by mental ill health felt and that it was doing enough to address it.

Despite this negativity, over half (54 per cent) of employers thought that attitudes towards mental ill health in the workplace have changed for the better in the past fifteen years. This compares with 30 per cent who said that they had not seen any change.

Dr Mark Winwood, director of clinical psychology at AXA PPP healthcare, says:

“Stress and mental health issues affect one in four people on average in any given year and one in six at any given time. With this rate of occurrence, we need to work harder to eliminate the stigma surrounding mental ill health. Businesses are well placed to lead the way to changing this harmful prejudice by giving their employees the necessary tools and support to enable them to discuss mental health in an open and unbiased way.

“Lack of understanding breeds fear so improving employees’ awareness and understanding of mental illness is one of the most important things a company’s senior management team can do and a critical first step is to challenge the stigma surrounding mental ill health in the workplace.

“Employers can begin by introducing a number of small but important changes such as promoting an open and honest culture where the facts about mental ill health are freely communicated and discussed. I have seen that senior managers who have been open and felt able to share their own experiences of mental health challenges and worries have often succeeded in developing an environment that is more accepting. Training and supporting managers to deal with employees affected by mental ill health (including letting them know what employee assistance programmes are available) will also help to give them the confidence to provide effective support where and when it is needed.” 

*Online survey of 1,000 employees and online survey of 1,000 senior business managers, MDs, CEOs and owners undertaken in February 2015 by market researcher OnePoll.